File A Claim
Aeigis General Insurance Agency
4507 N Front Street
Suite 200
Harrisburg, PA 17110-1787
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-662-5752
Online Payment Link
Claims: 800-233-2160
Agency Insurance Company (AIC)
PO Box 8900
Elkridge, MD 21075
Website
Customer Service: 800-492-5629
Online Payment Link
Claims: 800.841.5241
Allegany Co-Op
9 North Branch Rd.
Cuba, NY 14727
Website
Customer Service: tel
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Allstate Insurance
PO Box 660598
Dallas, TX 75266-0598
Website
Customer Service: 877-810-2920
Online Payment Link
Online Claims Link
American Modern Insurance
PO Box 5323
Cincinnati, OH 45201
Website
Customer Service: 800-543-2644
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link or call: 800-375-2075
Amtrust
800 Superior Avenue E.
21st Floor
Cleveland, OH 44114
Website
Customer Service: 1-877-528-7878
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Auto Owners
6101 Anacapri Blvd.
Lansing, MI 48917
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-346-034
Contact Info
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Central Co-Operative Insurance Company
6 Southgate Rd
Baldwinsville, NY 13027
Website
Customer Service: 315-635-7606
Contact Info
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Cincinnati Insurance Company
PO Box 145496
Cinncinnati, OH 45250-5496
Website
Customer Service: 1-888-242-0888
Online Payment Link
Claims: 1-877-242-2544
Dryden Mutual
12 Ellis Drive
P.O. Box 635
Dryden, NY 13053
Website
Customer Service: 800-724-0560
Contact Information
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Employers
PO Box 32036
Lakeland, FL 33802-2036
Website
Customer Service: 1-888-682-6671
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Erie & Niagra Insurance Association
PO Box 9062
Williamsville, NY 14231
Website
Customer Service: 1-716-632-5433
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Farmers & Mechanics Mutual
PO Box 900
Lititz, PA 17543
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-375-3252
Online Payment Link
Claims: 1-855-725-5642
Foremost Insurance Group
PO Box 0915
Carol Stream, IL 60132
Website
Customer Service: 1-888-888-0080
Online Payment Link
Online Claims Link
Claims (personal): 1-800-527-3907
Claims (auto): 1-800-274-7865
Claims (business): 1-800-435-7764
Grundy Insurance
400 Horsham Rd.
Horsham, PA 19044
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-338-4006
Online Payment Link
Online Claims Forms
Hagerty
PO Box 1303
Traverse City, MI 49685-1303
Website
Customer Service: 1-877-922-9701
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Form
Hanover Insurance Group
PO Box 580045
Charlotte, NC 28258
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-922-8427
Online Payment Link or 1-800-573-1187
Online Claims Link: 1-800-628-0250
Lititz Mutual Insurance Company
PO Box 900
2 North Broad Street
Lititz, PA 17543-7007
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-626-4751
Online Payment Link
Claims: 1-855-725-5642
Livingston Mutual Insurance Company
PO Box 900
2 North Broad Street
Lititz, PA 17543-7007
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-724-0074
Online Payment Link
Claims: 855-725-5642
Main Street America Group
220 Salina Meadows
Suite 200
Syracuse, NY 13212
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-962-5515
Online Payment Link
Claims: 1-877-425-2467
Merchants Insurance Group
250 Main Street
Buffalo, NY 14202
Website
Customer Service: 800-462-1077
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Millville Mutual
215 S. State Street
Millville, PA 17846
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-262-8495
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
MMG
44 Maysville Road
Presque Isle, ME 04769-3220
Website
Customer Service: or 1-888-664-2455
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Natural Catastrophe (Cat Coverage)
3785 South 700 East
Second Floor
Salt Lake City,UT 84106
Website
Claims: 801-316-4228
Online Payment Link
New York Central Mutual (NYCM)
3815 California Rd.
Orchard Park, NY 14127
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-234-6926
Online Payment Link
Claims: 1-800-234-6926
Plymouth Rock
PO Box 55933
Boston, MA 02205-5933
Website
Customer Service
Online Payment Link
Online Claims
Progressive Insurance
6300 Wilson Mills Rd.
Mayfield Village, OH 44143
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-776-4737
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Security Mutual Insurance Company
PO Box 4620
Ithaca, NY 14852-4620
Website
Customer Service: 1-607-257-500
Online Payment Link
Selective Insurance Company of America
PO Box 782747
401 Market Street
Philadephia, PA 19106
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-735-3284
Online Payment Link or call: 1-888-974-7400
Online Claims Link or call: 1-866-455-9969
Payments (regular)
Selective
Box 371468
Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7468
Payments (overnight)
Selective
500 Ross St.
Room 154-0470
Pittsburgh, PA 15262
ATTN: Box 371468
The Hartford
The Hartford
690 Asylum Avenue
Hartford, CT 06155
Website
Customer Service: 1-860-547-5000
Online Payment Link (personal)
Online Payment Link (business)
Online Claim Link
Travelers Insurance
Online Payment Link
Online Claims Link
Personal Insurance Payments
PO Box 660307
Dallas, TX 5266-0307
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-842-5075
Claims: 1-800-252-4633
Business Insurance Online Payments
Customer Service: 1-800-252-2268
Claims: 1-800-238-6225
Business Insurance Payments
Travelers CL Remittance Center
PO Box 660317
Dallas, TX 75266-0317
Universal Property and Casualty
1110 W.Commercial Blvd
Suite 300
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33309
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-425-9113
Online Payment Link
Online Claims Link or call: 1-800-470-0599
Utica National Insurance Group
PO Box 530
Utica, NY 13503-0530
Website
Customer Service: 1-866-860-1914
Online Payment Link
Online Claims Link
Contact Marshall Insurance: 814.363.7556 | Email Us
Get A Quote – Fast!
Fill out the short form below and we’ll get back to you ASAP with a quote that will make you smile! That’s our promise at Marshall Insurance.
